My friend Sean has a post up about
banned books week.
Here's the quote that got me thinking:
Of course there will always be subjects that you don't discuss with children because it is not age appropriate. But by high school, I think most topics are on the table. Other than the language of the time, I don't think anything in the book would offend the sensibilities of a high school reader. To pretend that you can 'protect' them inside a bubble of innocence is both unrealistic and hardly helpful in raising mature adults. And I think if parents and teens read To Kill a Mockingbird together, it would lead to some very worthwhile discussions.
Now that I have a daughter of my own, my opinions of what is on the library shelf have come into sharper focus. I don't think I have changed my mind in anyway - it's just that the
theoretical has become practical.
First of all, public libraries should be able to stock whatever they want. But when it comes to Elementary school, I want Annabelle to be exposed to positive and uplifting literature that helps her to see the beauty in the world - keep the political and controversial stuff to yourself.
When Annie hits middle school, I would expect her to be exposed to thoughts and ideas that are outside her belief system - in a way that affords her opinions respect but upholds dignity of those with whom she may disagree.
By the time Annie hits her senior year of high school, I would expect her to be exposed to literature that challenges her to defend her own opinions - possibly even persuade her to change her opinions about some things.
By the time Annie is 18 - she should be able to pull anything she wants off any library shelf in the world and deal with it in a thoughtful manner.
The trouble is, many parents do not feel the way I do. They fail to raise their children to be mature thinking adults so when they are challenged at school, their kids are wholly unprepared to deal with differing opinions.
I guess, in the end, I really don't much care what books are or are not banned from the school library - Annie is going to have her own library at home that will do the job. Raising my daughter is MY job - not that of the school system.
Annie will read To Kill a Mockingbird one way or another. If she doesn't she will at least watch the movie with Gregory Peck.
But not Catcher in the Rye - because that travesty is just a
sophomoric waste of space.